If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. Right?
That is the mantra we are taught as children and teenagers.
It is the story arc for almost any romantic comedy ever made – Boy meets Girl. Girl rejects boy. Boy pesters girl in evermore inventive ways until she gives in and they live happily ever after. It’s been called the ‘stalking for love’ trope.
But maybe there’s a time and place for perseverance, and it’s not when asking out a girl – that is what one aunt is teaching her teenage nephew in the US.
Her message gained extra potency after a school shooting which killed 10 in Santa Fe, Texas, USA on Friday. The mother of 16-year old victim Shana Fisher told media her daughter had “endured four months of problems” from the shooter and publicly rejected him days before the attack.
Many on social media are now debating how girls can respond to repeated romantic approaches or harassment from boys or men, and how boys should cope with unrequited love.
In a tweet shared almost 130,000 times, @adigoesswimming explained a conversation she had with her nephew after a girl turned him down.
My teenage nephew told me he asked a girl out and she turned him down. I said, “You know what to do now, right?” He said, “I know I know keep trying” and I said “NO. LEAVE HER ALONE. She gave you an answer.” He was shocked. NO ONE had told him that before. TEACH. YOUR. BOYS. https://t.co/yrxjNRnfk5
— 🌹 Witch, Hunting 💀 (@adigoesswimming) May 20, 2018
End of Twitter post by @adigoesswimming
“You know what do to now, right?” she asked him.
“I know, I know, keep trying,” he replied.
“No. Leave her alone. She gave you an answer,” his aunt responded.
@adigoesswimming then explained her nephew was shocked, and no-one had ever told him that before. “Teach. Your. Boys,” she concluded.
You might also be interested in:
- Actress gets China talking about periods
- Mum’s tough love lesson divides parents
- Soldier watches baby’s birth on FaceTime after flight delay
Her story chimed a chord with many, who shared their own experiences and views about respecting boundaries, especially with young love.
“We should downplay high school crushes, which leave such an imprint but are the product of very unformed ideas about character, romance, love, and life’s possibilities as well as brains that aren’t done growing,” commented L J Platt.
Chris Csernica suggested the problem may be that boys are generally taught that failure is not an option, but when applied to asking girls out, this advice is flawed.
The cause of confusion is obvious. In most every other area we encourage persistence in the face of failure. And in most every other area, this is correct. The difference is that another person’s affections must be freely given and not some kind of reward for one’s efforts.
— Chris Csernica (@chris_csernica) May 20, 2018
End of Twitter post by @chris_csernica
Suzanne Kco added movies and books coaching boys ‘not to give up’ are part of the problem, and that people who turn away romantic advances need to be respected.
@laurenduca someone needs to write a piece on this. movies, books etc all teach boys to “not give up”, as if gaining a woman’s affection is a trophy. It’s time to change that narrative. Women and men who say “no” should be respected, not harassed.
— SuzSnowflake ❄️ (@suzannekco) May 20, 2018
End of Twitter post by @suzannekco
Some parents shared their experience of teaching their sons to accept rejection.
“I am having this conversation with my son, who is extraordinarily shy. It’s important he learns rejection is not necessarily about him, and it’s really none of his business why a young woman would turn him down,” wrote @JTRJules
Maro Virino added, “I am raising my three boys to hear and accept No from girls without reacting nastily to rejection.”
“I asked my boys about this, up to the “do you know what to do now” point. I was glad to hear “find different girl” from both of them. They expanded, if she doesn’t want to go out with you, move on. I’m not a complete failure as a parent,” wrote Ayerene Isme.
However, some warned against such a cut-and-dry approach, pointing out times when a bit of perseverance led to a happy ending.
“I know someone who asked a young lady out, she said no. He asked her again, she said no. But he decided to ask her one more time. She said yes. Now they’ve been married for 30 years,” commented @PrezMisterSix.
Here’s where I’m confused. I know someone who asked a young lady out she said ” no” He asked her again she said ” no” But he decided to ask her one more time. She said yes. Now they’ve been married for 30 years.
— PrezMisterSix (@PrezMisterSix) May 20, 2018
End of Twitter post by @PrezMisterSix
Nick added, “My mum rejected my dad at first then eventually gave him a chance that turned into marriage. Persistence isn’t always a bad thing if done politely”, while advising “I would still suggest that boys not react nastily or be disrespectful to rejection.”