Skip to content

‘Design crimes’: How a bench launched a homelessness debate

May 13, 2018

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionProfessor Green removes Bournemouth’s ‘anti-homeless’ bench bars in January

A picture of a rainbow-coloured bench has launched a debate about homelessness, exclusion and hostile design on social media.

On Saturday, Twitter user Isaac Azuelos posted an image of a bench in his home town of Calgary, Canada.

The bench featured metal bars which prevent homeless people from sleeping there.

‘Design crimes’: How a bench launched a homelessness debate‘Design crimes’: How a bench launched a homelessness debate

Mr Azuelos’ tweet was widely shared and other users posted their own examples, some using the hashtag #HostileDesign.

Skip Twitter post by @isaacazuelos

When you’re inclusive but still hate the poor. pic.twitter.com/WB1kTuxXkb

— Isaac Azuelos (@isaacazuelos) May 12, 2018

End of Twitter post by @isaacazuelos

You might also like:

Some saw the design as evidence of the marginalisation and exclusion of homeless people from public spaces.

Skip Twitter post by @ThisMicah

These are designed specifically to prevent tired people from laying down on them. It’s a feature, not a bug. Don’t act like it’s an innocent byproduct of a legitimate design need.

— ThisMicah (@ThisMicah) May 14, 2018

End of Twitter post by @ThisMicah

“These are designed specifically to prevent tired people from laying down on them,” wrote Twitter user @ThisMicah.

“It’s a feature, not a bug,” the tweet continued.

“I think the problem is that society tells them they’re a problem and shuns them from public spaces,” wrote another.

“But that doesn’t solve the issue, [it] just pushes it out of sight. Maybe by treating homeless people like humans they can actually progress rather than be a ‘problem’.”

But others questioned why people should be allowed to sleep on public benches.

Skip Twitter post by @lainey1808

So every park bench design should have the prerequisite that it must accommodate people who want to sleep on them?

— Lainey B (@lainey1808) May 14, 2018

End of Twitter post by @lainey1808

And some pointed out that bars can provide support and assistance to the elderly or less physically able.

Skip Twitter post by @oxytocinated

ever thought about old people who need something to hold on to to get up and down? Pretty sure it’s rather for them then against homeless people slepping there.

— charly (@oxytocinated) May 13, 2018

End of Twitter post by @oxytocinated

“Ever thought about old people who need something to hold onto to get up and down?” asked one.

“Pretty sure it’s rather for them than against homeless people sleeping there.”

The debate has captured the interest of many. Mr Azuelos’ original tweet has generated significant discussion online and tens of thousands of likes and retweets.

On Sunday, he posted a screenshot of a conversation he had with the organisation which runs the site where the bench was installed, Springboard Performance.

“The bench was actually a donation to our non-profit by city workers, specifically for an elderly patron who walks by every day” a spokesperson said.

“The intent was not to institute or uphold the principles of hostile or exclusionary design.”

Skip Facebook post by Stuart Semple

This is wonderful! Twitter is literally blowing up about Hostile Design! https://twitter.com/i/moments/995867236349837313

Posted by Stuart Semple on Monday, 14 May 2018

End of Facebook post by Stuart Semple

British artist Stuart Semple has previously used social media to shine a spotlight on examples of hostile design.

In February, he set up a website to document what he describes as “designs against humanity” after seeing benches fitted with “anti-homeless” bars in Bournemouth, Dorset. He posted an image of one of the benches to Facebook in January which, he claims, was viewed more than a million times inside 24 hours.

Bournemouth council officials later announced that all bars would be removed following protests.

Skip Facebook post 2 by Stuart Semple

Big shout out to Bournemouth Bournemouth council for their latest Design Crime. This latest piece of hostile design is…

Posted by Stuart Semple on Saturday, 27 January 2018

End of Facebook post 2 by Stuart Semple

Social media users contribute to Mr Semple’s campaign by tagging pictures on Instagram with the hashtag #HostileDesign. Pictures featured in the website’s gallery include examples from Milan, New York and Toronto.

Skip Instagram post by sydneymluken

#hostiledesign spotted at Q & 22

A post shared by S M L (@sydneymluken) on Mar 23, 2018 at 5:08am PDT

End of Instagram post by sydneymluken

Receive Breaking News !

Install
×
Enable Notifications    Ok No thanks